Melodrama in two acts, with prologue.
Advertised as a 'the thrilling and sensational drama - the story of an impersonation' (Argus 9 July 1909, p12), A Miner's Trust comprises a prologue (set in Australia) and the main body of the play, which is set largely in England. Several characters from the prologue reprise their roles in the following acts.
The story concerns a promise made by Alan Trengrove to his blind sweetheart Alice Medway that he would make his fortune so that they might one day marry. Ten years later he finally achieves his financial goal after having worked on the Australian goldfields, most of this time in partnership with his friend, Jack Howard. However, before he can return to England to fulfil his promise Trengrove is mortally wounded in a robbery attempt by a New Caledonian escapee, Gaston De Rougue. As he is dying Trengrove implores his mate to go to England in his stead, impersonate him (as the shock of his death would be too much for the poor girl), and then marry her. The Age theatre critic writes that the 'rest of the action takes place on British soil. The author trots out the somewhat villainous cousin and the elderly lawyer with which most of us are familiar, and he also gives us two or three graceful girls, who make perhaps as much as possible of the unremarkable dialogue. There is also a shipwreck scene, which furnishes a vivid piece of realism in the second act' (10 July 1909, p14).
The Argus critic also makes special note of the shipwreck sensation scene, recording: 'The great scene - and a great scene, chiefly by the mechanical and artistic departments, is necessary for every strenuous melodrama of today - is the wreck of an Australian liner, for which the entire breadth and depth of the stage is required' (10 July 1909, p20).
Although the critics were generally divided in their opinion of the overall success of this melodrama, all appear to agree that its faults lay mostly in the dramatic construction rather than in the incidents of the story. The Argus' largely positive review reports in this respect : 'It is a good stage play, in some portions excellent and its web is bound closer than almost any other work by an Australian author.' The paper's critic notes, however, that the drama's complications add to the interest at times but at others work to detract from it' (10 July 1909, p20).
Less favourable were reviews in the Age and Bulletin. The latter's 'Sundry Shows' editor writes for example : 'The prologue promises more than the drama fulfils; nevertheless the developments from the prologue are ingenious in design if faulty in execution' (15 July 1909, p9). The Age theatre critic writes less favourably : 'Friendly as was last night's reception, it is impossible, unfortunately, to say much in favour of the play as a representative specimen of Australian made drama... The work as a whole lacks originality and lacks distinction. Nor does the plot commend itself by any startling freshness of ideas... [it is, however], admirably staged and mounted' (10 July 1909, p14).
1909 : Theatre Royal, Melbourne ; 9-14 July (5 performances). Dir. C. R. Stanford ; Prod. Rupert Clarke, Clyde Meynall and John Gunn ; Mngr. Arthur Levy ; Music Dir. F. Wynne Jones ; Scenic Art Phil Goatcher and E. Vaughan. Prologue Cast: Herbert J. Bentley (Alan Trengrove), Augustus Neville (Jack Howard, his mate), J. B. Atholwood (Gaspard De Rouge, an escapee), F. Coape (Tom Gaffney, Landlord of the California Arms), J. R. Howard (Joe Brown, an Ostler), Gordon Thomas (O'Grady, a trooper), Leo De Chateau (Paddy Frere, a miner), J. F. Walters (Mansfield, a miner), G. A. Fenton (Boyle, a miner), H. S. Lewis (Sampson, a miner), Nellie Florence (Kate Gaffney). Play cast incl. Herbert J. Bentley (Alan Trengrove), Hilliard Vox (Arthur Trengrove), Leo De Chateau (Mr Probit, a lawyer), Wilson Forbes (Captain Medway, a retired Naval Officer), Lance Vane (Algernon Fairburn, of the Royal Navy), Harry Halley (Bill Bobstay, the Captain's man), G. A. Denton (Barney Byrne, a Coastguardsman), F. Coape (Sergeant Grant, of Bow Street), G. H. Emery (Officer Durant, of Paris), J. B. Atholwood (Gaspard De Rouge), Alice Deorwyn (Aunt Hypatia, the Captain's sister), Lilian Myers (Ida Medway, the Captain's daughter), Mabel Russell (Florrie Medway, her sister), Beatrice Holloway (Alice Medway, the Captain's niece).