Watson sent the manuscript to
Joseph Conrad (q.v.) who read it seven times and made thirty-one pages of notes. On the 2 September 1913 Conrad wrote: 'It had seven readings - not all by me alone, however. I perceived at once (and with great sympathy) that your work was concerned with the right things, but that you did not always express them in the right way.' Watson records that 'They wanted me to rewrite the whole thing, as a long short story of about forty thousand words. This they said would make it a real artisitic success, but my thought was swift and obstinate:- would I ever get it published at that length? ... I compromised with the determination that I could accept a good eighty per cent of their emendations, but that probably I would have to keep it as a novel' (Grant-Watson,
But to What Purpose (q.v.), pp. 149-150).