Haigh's biography Mystery Spinner, which documents the life of Australian spin bowler, Jack Iverson, was shortlisted for the William Hill Sports Book of the Year, 2000 and won the PricewaterhouseCoopers Cricket Book of the Year Award, 2000. Prize money for the latter award was 1,500 pounds sterling. In 2006 Haigh was awarded the Westfield/Waverley Library Prize for Literature for Asbestos House : The Secret History of James Hardie Industries.
Haigh's other books include Game for Anything (2004), a collection of his cricket writing, and Asbestos House (2006), for which he was shortlisted in the 2006 Walkley Awards for Best Non-Fiction Book and was the winner in the 2006 Blake Dawson Waldron Prize for Business Literature and the 2007 New South Wales Premier's Literary Award, Gleebooks Prize. Haigh's The Racket: How Abortion Became Legal in Australia (2008) was shortlisted for the Gleebooks Prize in the 2009 New South Wales Premier's Literary Awards. His works on the history of economic life include The Office: A Hardworking History (2012), which was shortlisted for the Melbourne Prize for Literature, and won the Australian Publishers' Association Best Designed Non-fiction Book Award (2013).
Haigh was shortlisted for the 2010 Alfred Deakin Prize for an Essay Advancing Public Debate, Victorian Premier's Awards, for 'Stupid Money' which was published in the Griffith Review.